The World of Rare Coins
Rare Coins as an Investment
Stability over the Long Term
Rare coins have been actively traded for profit since the 17th Century. The legendary House of Rothchild
(famed European banking family) actually got its start dealing in rare coins. Meyer Rothchild, the founder
of the banking empire, began selling rare coins and medals at Frankfurt's great spring and autumn fairs.
Between fairs, he ran a mail-order coin business. Starting in 1771, he published the first of many
printed coin catalogs, which he sent out at regular intervals over the next 20 years. To this day,
many prestigious European banks maintain active numismatic departments.
In the modern era, the trading of coins has been enhanced by the creation of a well-established market
structure for determining the quality and quantity of rare coins in the marketplace. In 1986, the
Professional Coin Grading Service (PCGS) was established. About one year later, a worthy rival, the
Numismatic Guaranty Corporation (NGC), came into existence. These two firms established a uniform
coin-grading standard that has gained almost universal acceptance throughout the world. Additionally,
there are two highly efficient computerized trading networks (patterned after the NASDAQ) that provide
a live Bid/Ask market for coins on both a "sight" and "sight unseen" basis.
The underlying financial dynamic that drives value in the rare coin market is actually very simple:
there is a defined, limited supply of these numismatic rarities while demand (in the form of the number
of collectors interested in acquiring them) has continued to grow. For over three hundred years, demand
has steadily increased while the supply has remained fixed. The basic principals of supply and demand
work in rare coins as they do in any economic venture and there is no reason to believe that this
dynamic will change. While prices will fluctuate in the short term, rare coins have a long, well-chronicled
history of appreciating handsomely in value over time.
Superior Capital Appreciation
Rare Coins have consistently outperformed the stock market over time. These graphs provide a comparison
that reveals how rare coins have outperformed the Dow Jones Industrial average over time. The 12 Piece
Gold Set has outperformed the DJIA by 5 to 1 since 1970. Providing comparisons between different investment
vehicles can be tricky so it's important to understand what's being compared.
- 12 Piece Gold Set: The 12 Piece Gold Set is an industry index that is used frequently within
the world of rare coins for financial evaluations. It is an index like the DJIA is an index, meaning it
is designed to represent the composite performance of a given market. It consists of the 12 U.S. Gold
coins that have been most commonly traded over the last 50 years. It's important to note that being
commonly traded does not mean that they are the best performing coins in terms of appreciation in value.
In fact, there are several pieces in the 12 Piece Gold Set that have not performed well over the time
periods presented and Superior would not recommend buying them today. Unlike the DJIA, however, these
12 pieces are a constant over the entire time period being analyzed.
- Dow Jones Industrial Average: The Dow Jones Industrial Average consists of 30 companies.
The 30 companies in today's DJIA are not the same as the 30 companies in 1970, though. Some companies
have been dropped and others added for a variety of reasons, including poor financial performance.
For example, Johns-Manville was dropped when it entered bankruptcy and Chrysler was dropped when it
approached bankruptcy. As a result, the DJIA actually presents the performance of stocks in a better
light because poor performing companies have been dropped from the index. Of course, the DJIA does
not include stock dividends, which might be re-invested and increase the overall performance of the equities.
Even with the advantage of dropping poor performing stocks from the DJIA index, rare U.S. Gold coins
still have a far superior track record for capital appreciation.
Coins are the "quantifiable collectible." Well-established third party sources provide data on quality
(through coin grading services) and quantity (through population reports) of coins available. You can
also readily access public information about recent sale prices for virtually any type of coin.
Rare coins are also a very liquid investment as there are several NASDAQ like trading networks
available for selling coins as well as regularly scheduled auctions and coin shows.
In summary, rare coins offer you tremendous profit potential, a proven track record of appreciation, and
an infrastructure for buying and selling that rivals the equities market. No wonder so many financial
advisors agree that rare coins should be a part of any appropriately diversified portfolio.
Rare Coins as a Hobby
A Unique Blend of Art, History, and Finance
Since the dawn of civilization, coins have been highly esteemed for their beauty and appeal as a solid
store of wealth. For thousands of years, gold coins in particular have maintained their value.
In fact, gold's purchasing power has remained in tact since the 17th century. The ancient Greeks
adored coins and were the first to promote coinage to the station of an art form. Coins were regarded
as miniature sculptures and were created by the finest artisans of the time. Romans admired the
Greek coinage and followed suit to further enhance the art form.
The ultimate, modern rendition of this ancient art form is the 1907 Roman Numeral $20 gold piece.
Designed by famed sculptor Augustus St. Gaudens, the creation of this coin was inspired by the high
relief motif of the ancient Greek and Roman coins. Theodore Roosevelt personally commissioned St.
Gaudens to sculpt the gold piece despite vehement opposition from congress and Chief Engraver Charles
Barber. With every coin, there is a story. Learning the stories associated with the art and history
of each coin is part of the timeless fascination of coin collecting.
The Virtues of Being A Collector First and an Investor Second
It is possible to invest in rare coins purely as economic vehicles and enjoy excellent financial
returns from that investment. History has shown, however, that the greatest financial returns have
been achieved by those who regarded themselves as collectors first…and investors second.
In rare coins, the whole is truly greater than the sum of the parts. Establishing a strategy for
a collection and then patiently and systematically acquiring the best pieces that match your strategy
can yield extraordinary results.
Consider the story of Baltimore banker Louis Eliasberg, a legend among rare coin collectors.
Louis Eliasberg, Sr. began collecting coins about 1925. He pursued the hobby casually during the
growth years of his finance business. In the 1930's he began in earnest to develop a world-class
collection. Mr. Eliasberg invested a total of $400,000 in his collection from 1925-1950. His
heirs were the beneficiaries of his exceptional foresight and patience. The collection, sold in
portions from 1982 to 1997, yielded $44.5 million dollars!
The passion for collecting may not strike you full force initially. You may wish to begin gradually,
both in your education and your coin acquisitions. If that's the case, Superior Galleries may be
the perfect fit for you. Superior is firmly committed to assisting its clients every step of the
way toward a satisfying and profitable experience in the numismatic marketplace.
As with any investment, investing for the long-term and making quality investments are crucial to
success. Superior's advisors also believe that you should capitalize on short-term profit
opportunities when they arise, however.
Rare Coins Compared to Other Collectibles
Rare coins stand out as a superior investment when compared to other collectibles, especially for
someone looking to diversify their investment portfolio into the world of collectibles for the first
time. Unlike paintings, sports memorabilia, or many other forms of collectibles, the rare coin market
is characterized by well-established standards for determining the quality of a given coin and a stock
market like infrastructure for ensuring the liquidity of your investment.
The Quantifiable Collectible
Not only is there a long history of capital appreciation, rare coins are also the "quantifiable
collectible." Most of the key attributes that determine value in rare coins, including the quality
of the coin and the number in circulation (supply), can be readily determined.
The grade, or state of preservation, of a coin plays a critical role in determining a coin's value.
Rare coins are graded on a numerical scale from 0 to 70. Zero represents basal state and 70 represents
an uncirculated (or mint state) specimen that is perfect in every respect. The higher its numerical
grade, the more valuable a coin is to collectors. A one-point difference, not even discernable to
the untrained eye, can easily mean thousands of dollars of difference in value. Therefore, the
importance of consistent grading, according to a universally accepted standard, cannot be overstated.
The Professional Coin Grading Service (PCGS) was founded in 1986. About one year later, the Numismatic
Guaranty Corporation (NGC), a worthy competitor, was formed. These two firms established a uniform
coin grading standard, which has gained almost universal acceptance throughout the world. In addition
to establishing the grades for individual coins, both the PCGS and the NGC publish a monthly survey of
all the coins that they have graded. In combination with a coin's grade, these "population reports"
are extremely important tools for establishing the value of a given coin. The grade and the population
report provide the investor with the baseline information regarding the supply side of the supply and
demand equation. Other coin grading services have emerged subsequently but these two services are the
industry giants and Superior advises against relying upon grading from other services to establish market value.
Superior's strategy for creating value for its customers is predicated upon identifying coins that are
truly rare (limited in supply) for which there has been strong historical demand. Such a strategy
minimizes the risk associated with unexpected fluctuations in supply (new coins from a particular
series being graded for the first time) or fad driven spikes in demand. Furthermore, Superior advocates
investing only in high quality coins, those that have a high grade from PCGS or NGC. In summary, Superior
recommends that you can achieve optimal results by using this data to invest only in highly graded coins
that the population reports indicate are truly rare (fewer than 1,000 coins in their total graded
populations) and for which there is proven demand from collectors over a long period of time.
PCGS and NGC are roughly analogous to Moody's or Standard and Poor's in the bond rating industry. Their
data are completely unbiased but their data may not be completely accurate and the data, in isolation,
is not sufficient to determine long-term market value. For example, PCGS and NGC have no way of
determining if a coin has been removed from its holder and resubmitted, thereby increasing the
population without an additional coin being graded. Furthermore, PCGS and NGC do not know how many
coins in a particular series have never been submitted for grading. These ungraded coins represent
a potential change in supply. That is among the reasons Superior advises against investing in coins
for which there is a large initial circulation, even if the grades and population reports indicate
that a coin might be rare. The risk or more coins from that large, initial circulation being submitted
for grading, thus increasing supply unpredictably, is simply too great.
Liquidity
The advent of certified grading led to another important development in the rare coin investment
environment, the formation of the Certified Coin Exchange (CCE) in 1990. This nationwide, computerized
trading network for rare coins functions much like the over-the-counter stock markets do today,
assuring liquidity among market makers. CCE is also the number one source for instantaneous pricing
information. Live Bid/Ask quotations are available on both a "sight" and "sight unseen" basis.
Subsequently, other reputable exchanges have been founded, including Coin Net and Eureka Trading Systems.
Furthermore, there are dozens of well-advertised auctions yearly; Superior is a leader in the auction
field and can assist you in realizing the top value when selling your rare coins. Finally,
well-attended coins shows take place on an almost weekly basis across the United States. In their
totality, these channels result in rare coins being the most liquid collectible of all.
Long Term Track Record
Rare coins have been valued since antiquity and have been actively traded for fun and profit since the
17th century. The rare coin market continues to thrive today. Worldwide, it is estimated that there
are in excess of 100 million collectors, with as many as 10 million of those in the U.S. alone. Coin
collecting is not a passing fad. In contrast, sports cards, comic books, and other forms of
collectibles are relatively recent phenomena…and they have no intrinsic value whatsoever!
From the King of Siam in the early 1800's to King Farouk of Egypt 150 years later, rare coins have
been enthusiastically collected and traded. Given this and the mature market for establishing value
and facilitating trading, collectibles have been correctly dubbed "the collectible of kings and the
king of collectibles." If you choose to diversify your portfolio into only one form of collectible,
Superior Galleries believes your best choice is clearly rare coins.
|